Apply for class 03 now!

Evaluation

The Prototype Fund has been continuously evaluated since its inception in 2016. The focus of the evaluation is on the question of how funding programs can be designed to be accessible, inclusive, and oriented towards the common good.

Data basis and data collection methods of the evaluation

The information below is based on funding data collected by the Prototype Fund as part of the application and funding process. They are usually complete. In addition, the Prototype Fund's accompanying research has regularly collected supplementary data since 2016, the Technopolis GmbH collected additional data once in 2023. They conducted online surveys and interviews with samples of applicants and grantees before, during and after the funding period.

Last revision: 18.09.2026

Who applies to the Prototype Fund?

01 How many applications does the Prototype Fund receive?

On average, 291 teams or individuals submitted a project to the Prototype Fund per year or round. As in Round 1, which saw a particularly high number of applications, competition was particularly fierce in the current Class 02. With an average of 23 funded projects per round, 7.9% of the applications submitted were funded on average.

Diagramme showing the number of applications for the Prototype Fund for rounds 1 through 16 as well as Classes 01 through 02. The highest number of applications was 479 in round 1, the lowest was 150 in round 13. The mean over all rounds and Classes is 275.

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 1-16 and Classes 01-02, N=4.943.

02 Do people reapply after an unsuccessful application?

Among grantees and unsuccessful applicants from rounds 1-12 and the special round WirVsVirus, almost two thirds stated that they had previously applied in vain at least once. Among applicants for Classes 01 and 02, the proportion of people who had previously applied unsuccessfully was only one third and therefore significantly lower.

Bar chart showing whether or how many times grantees and unsuccessful applicants had previously applied in vain: 36% never, 32% once, 16% twice, 9% three times, 2% four times and 5% more than four times.

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees, n=163, and unsuccessful applicants, n=17, for rounds 1-12 and WirVsVirus (see Technopolis Evaluation Report 2023, p. 68).

Bar chart showing whether or how many times applicants had previously applied in vain: 68% never, 24% once, 4% twice, 1% three times, 0% four times and 4% more than four times.

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online surveys among applicants for Classes 01 and 02, n=174.

03 Do more teams or individuals apply?

In previous application rounds, slightly more teams than individuals applied on average. This trend was slightly more pronounced in Years 01 and 02.

Teams-Individuals_Applications_R1-16

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 2-16, N=3.749.

Teams-Individuals_Applications_C01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for Classes 01-02, N=715.

04 How experienced are applicants with regard to public funding?

Applicants to the Prototype Fund rate their experience with public funding programs as low. Both in rounds 1-12 and 15-16 and in Classes 01 and 02, the proportion of those who stated that they had no experience or only basic knowledge of public funding was 81%. Overall, these figures indicate that the Prototype Fund was able to achieve its goal of addressing target groups that are not usually reached by public funding.

Knowledge-Funding_R1-12-a-15-16

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees and unsuccessful applicants for rounds 1-12 and WirVsVirus, n=176 (see Technopolis Evaluation Report 2023, p. 13) / Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey of grantees and unsuccessful applicants for rounds 15-16, n=68.

Knowledge-Funding_Y01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey among applicants for Classes 01 and 02, n=174.

05 How experienced are applicants with regard to software development?

Applicants to the Prototype Fund rate their previous experience in the field of software programming as the highest. In contrast, around a third of the applicants surveyed stated that they had no or only basic knowledge of working in open source communities or programming free and open source software (FOSS). This shows that people who have previously programmed proprietary software and little or no FOSS have also applied to the Prototype Fund.

Knowledge-Development_Rounds1-12-WirVsVirus-u-15-16

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees and unsuccessful applicants for rounds 1-12 and WirVsVirus, n=176 (see Technopolis Evaluation Report 2023, p. 13) / Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey of grantees and unsuccessful applicants for rounds 15-16, n=68.

Knowledge-Development_Y01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey among applicants for Classes 01 and 02, n=174.

In terms of project management and project design, more than half of the respondents rated their knowledge as advanced or at expert level. The majority said that they were less experienced in communication and public relations. Around two thirds stated that they had no or only basic knowledge in this area. Overall, applicants from Classes 01 and 02 rated their prior knowledge as significantly higher than applicants from previous rounds.

06 How do grantees and applicants find out about the Prototype Fund?

Applicants most frequently learnt about the Prototype Fund through their personal network. Media such as news blogs, newsletters, mailing lists or social media as well as events also led an average of around a fifth of applicants to the Prototype Fund.

Knowledge-Funding_R1-16

Data: Open Konwledge Foundation, based on surveys among grantees of rounds 1-3, 5-6 and 9-16, n=229.

Knowledge-Funding_C01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online surveys among applicants for Classes 01 and 02, n=174, and among grantees of Class 01, n=21.

Which projects are submitted to the Prototype Fund?

01 Which funding priority received the most applications by 2024?

Until its relaunch in 2024, the Prototype Fund funded not only projects with a focus on Software Infrastructure and Data Security but also Civic Tech and Data Literacy. In rounds 1-16, more than half of the applicants assigned their project idea to the funding priority Civic Tech. About one in four applications was understood by the applicants as Software Infrastructure. Data Literacy and Data Security were significantly less represented in the applications, each accounting for around 10% of applications. As the four funding priorities cannot be clearly distinguished from one another, these self-assignments primarily provide insights into the applicants' main objectives.

Funding-priorities_Applications_Rd1-16

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on the self-assignment of the grant recipients from rounds 1-16 at the time of application, N=4.228.

02 Would the projects have been developed without the Prototype Fund?

Many of the funded projects would probably not have been developed without the Prototype Fund. In a survey of grantees from rounds 1-12 by the Technopolis Group, 55% stated that they would not have realised their project idea without funding. A corresponding proportion of 60% did not pursue projects that had previously been rejected by the Prototype Fund. 16% stated that they would have developed their project from their own resources without the Prototype Fund, but on a different, usually much smaller scale and over a longer period of time. The same proportion stated that they had developed their project in that way after it had been rejected by the Prototype Fund.

At the time of applying to the Prototype Fund, most of the applicants for Classes 01 and 02 planned to continue their project without the funding. For 40% of them, however, other funding was a prerequisite. Around a third planned to pursue their project idea at their own expense. In some cases, other options such as donation funding, start-up grants or a combination of different funding sources were also considered. Only 7 % of applicants ruled out pursuing their project without funding from the Prototype Fund.

Development-without-Funding_C01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey of applicants for Classes 01-02, n=174.

Who are the grantees of the Prototype Fund?

01 Do more teams or individuals receive funding?

On average, more teams than individuals received funding for projects. While 59% of applications for rounds 2-16 and 63% of applications for Classes 01 and 02 were from teams, teams accounted for only 52% and 60% of funded projects respectivly.

Teams-Individuals_Funding-Projects_R1-16

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 1-16, N=352.

Teams-Individuals_Funding-Projects_C01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for Classes 01-02, N=48.

02 Where do grantees live?

An analysis of grantees' places of residence shows that the Prototype Fund reaches people from all over Germany. However, certain regions are more frequently represented than others. Berlin is significantly over-represented, accounting for 49% in Rounds 1–16 and 45% in Classes 01–02. There also tends to be a higher proportion of grantees from Bavaria and Hamburg than from the other states. Since Class 01, it has also been possible to receive funding for residents of other European states. In Classes 01 and 02, they have accounted for 10% of grantees.

Wohnorte_Gefoerderte_Rd1-16

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 1-16, N=352.

Places-of-residence_Grantees_C01-02

Data: based on funding data for Classes 01 and 02, N=96.

03 Which gender do grantees categorise themselves as?

Surveys with grantees show that the majority of those who categorise themselves as one gender identify as male. In rounds 1-16 and the WirVsVirus special round, the proportion was 74%, in Class 01 67% identified as male. Female grantees made up 22% and only 5% in Class 01. 4% and 10%, respectively, identified as non-binary.
Overall, the proportion of women among Prototype Fund grantees roughly corresponds to that of computer science students in Germany in the winter semester of 2023/24 (Statistisches Bundesamt 2024). In many large open source projects, however, women often make up far less than 10% of contributors (NGI4ALL.E 2024).

Gender_Grantees_R1-16-a-WirVsVirus

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees from rounds 1-12 and WirVsVirus, n=156 (see Technopolis-Evauationsbericht, p. 11) / Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey among grantees from rounds 13-16, n=164.

Gender_Grantees_C01

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey of grantees from Class 01, n=21.

04 How often do individuals receive funding more than once?

17 % of grantees from rounds 1-16 and Classes 01-02 received funding more than once. The vast majority of them received funding twice. Significantly fewer people received funding for three or even four projects.

Multiple-Funding_R1-16-a-C01-02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 1-16 and Classes 01-02, N=791.

Which projects are supported by the Prototype Fund?

01 How many projects are funded?

The Prototype Fund gave out funding to a total of 373 projects in rounds 1-16 and year 01. An average of 22 projects were supported per funding round.

Anzahl_Foerderprojekte_Rd1-Jg02

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on funding data for rounds 1-16, #WirVsVirus and Classes 01-02, N=435.

02 How much money has been invested in open source projects with the Prototype Fund?

To date, the Prototype Fund has provided a total of around 18 million euros for the development of open-source projects. In rounds 1–16, every project – with the exception of those in the first two funding rounds – received an average of between 41,000 and 46,000€. This means that many projects came close to reaching the maximum grant amount of 47,500€. In rounds 1 and 2, the maximum grant amount was still 30,000€, and the projects in these rounds consequently received slightly less, namely between 24,000 and 28,000€. From Class 01 onwards, the maximum grant amount was increased again, to €158,300 for teams and €79,150 for individual developers receiving Second-Stage funding, and to 95,000€ for teams or 47,500€ for individual developers receiving only regular funding. Accordingly, the average grant amount per project in Class 01 was €78,758.

Funding-amounts_R1-C01

Data: based on funding data for projects of rounds 1-16, #WirVsVirus and Class 01, N=407.

03 Which funding priority received the most funding for projects up to 2024?

Until its relaunch in 2024, the Prototype Fund funded not only projects with a focus on Software Infrastructure and Data Security but also Civic Tech and Data Literacy. In rounds 1-16, the distribution of projects across the Prototype Fund's four funding priorities largely matched that of applications. This means that around half of the funded projects were assigned to Civic Tech at the application stage and around one in four applications was understood as software infrastructure. Data literacy and data security were funded somewhat less frequently. As the four funding pillars cannot be clearly distinguished from one another, the self-assignments shown in the diagram primarily provide information about the main objectives of the funding recipients at the time of their application.

Funding-priorities_Projects_Rd1-16

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on the self-assignment of the grant recipients from rounds 1-16 at the time of application, N=339.

What happens after funding?

01 What development status do the projects reach until the end of the funding period?

During the six- or ten-month funding period, around two-thirds of the funded projects have, in the past, been developed into either a complete, functional prototype or a published test version.

Project-development_R1-16-a-WirVsVirus

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees, n=123 (see Technopolis Evaluation Report 2023, p. 15).

Project-devlopment_C01

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey of grantees from Class 01, n=16.

02 Was sind die wichtigsten positiven Effekte auf die Geförderten?

Prototype Fund grantees report that they have benefited from the funding in a variety of ways. A key benefit for grantees is that they experience personal fulfilment as well as freedom and financial security during the funding period. Around half of the grantees also report that they have benefitted from the recognition and visibility their work received, from the development or expansion of their skills, and from building new contacts and networks. New professional and volunteering opportunities rarely arise immediately after the funding period has ended.

Positive-effects_C01

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an online survey among grantees of Class 01, n=21.

03 How do the projects develop after funding?

Of the projects from rounds 1-14 whose code was published on GitHub, 36% have undergone active further development through new commits in the past six months (as of 02/2025). A significant proportion of the projects therefore remain in the same place in the long term. In contrast, at least half of the projects are not continuously developed further in their project repositories. There can be various reasons for this. It is possible, for example, that a project was designed from the outset to be completed within the funding period or that a project proved to be impossible or impractical to realise. Another possibilities is that no follow-up funding has been found and that previous grantees are not available for voluntary development work. In some cases, project results are also used elsewhere in follow-up projects with separate repositories.

Repositories-after-funding_Rd1-14

Data: Open Knowledge Foundation, based on an analysis of project repositories on GitHub for rounds 1-14 using the Octosuite analysis software, N=305.

04 How is the development of the projects financed after funding?

At the time of a survey in summer 2023, many projects had not received any follow-up funding. One reason is that there is a funding gap in the FOSS sector for further developing ‘early stage’ applications such as those developed at the Prototype Fund. However, not all grantees are seeking follow-up funding and continue working on their projects on a voluntary basis instead. Among projects that are able to acquire follow-up funding, foundations, NGOs and public funders are the most common sources.

Follow-up-funding_Projects_Rd1-12

Data: Technopolis Group, based on an online survey among grantees of rounds 1-12 and WirVsVirus, n=119, multiple responses possible (see Technopolis Evaluation Report 2023, p. 22).

These are examples of development paths that can be observed among the projects which are being developed in the long term:

  1. Community projects, i.e. projects that are supported by a predominantly volunteer developer community and have built up their own community (e.g. drip and StreetComplete) or have been integrated into an existing community project (e.g. Generalisation of OpenStreetMap-Daten with osm2pgsql)
  2. Projects that are financed by a grant (e.g. FrameTrail)
  3. Projects financed by donations (e.g. Mastodon: Mobile Apps and E2E Encryption)
  4. Projects with a commercial business model such as software as a service (e.g. pretix), customised further development (e.g. FixMyBerlin) or licensing of data (e.g. OpenSanctions)

How has the Prototype Fund evolved over time?

01 Development between 2016 and 2024

As a learning funding programme, the Prototype Fund was continuously developed during its first term. Important changes were:

  • 2017: After the second round, the maximum funding amount was increased from €30,000 to €47,500 and the required own contribution was reduced accordingly from 40% to 5%.
  • 2020: From the eighth round onwards, all funding rounds were open to all topics. Previously, key topics were specified for each round, on the basis of which projects were selected for funding.
  • 2022: A wiki for information on the funding process and a knowledge base for information on project development were set up to facilitate a better exchange of knowledge between funding recipients.
02 Development from 2024

At the end of 2024, the Prototype Fund was redesigned in a new funding guideline.

  • 2024: The most important changes include focussing on the funding priorities of data security and software infrastructure, increasing the maximum funding amount and the option of adding a four-month second-stage grant to the six-month basic grant.
  • 2026: With Class 03, the Prototype Fund two fundings tracks to the programme. The previous funding priorities, data security and software infrastructure, are now part of the funding track Innovation. In addition, there the new fundings tracks Resilience and Up and Coming. In total, up to 50 projects are now funded each year in the regular funding period and up to 25 in the Second Stage of the funding programme. Previously, the maximum was 30 and 15 projects, respectively.