Apply for class 03 now!

keep calm and apply on

  • From the Prototype Fund
  • Application & funding
  • Picture: Willi Heidelbach / Pixabay

Time for lessons learned and feedback! As we prepare to open our application platform again, we want to review why some projects were unsuccessful last time.

To start with, receiving more than 450 applications for just 30 funding spots in class 02 means that we had to reject some excellent ideas and well-written proposals. Not being funded doesn't necessarily mean that your idea is bad; sometimes, it's simply a case of someone else presenting their project slightly better, and that makes all the difference.

Having said that, most unsuccessful proposals could be significantly improved by avoiding a few common mistakes. We have compiled the most frequent ones and provide tips on how to avoid them in your next application, whether to the Prototype Fund or any other fund.

1. Save yourself from basic mistakes, read the docs

No matter how good your idea is, if you get the formalities wrong, your application will be rejected immediately without being considered.

Fortunately, getting the formalities right is quite straightforward compared to other aspects of writing a funding proposal — it merely requires some reading and attention to detail. Funders often put a lot of effort into providing good documentation for applicants because clear communication about how to submit a good application saves everyone time. At Prototype Fund, we recommend reading our application page and application checklist at a minimum. Those who want more guidance can also refer to our full application guide, which provides insights into how to answer each question in our application form. We are currently updating all these pages and information with the latest updates for class 03, everything will be up to date by the time the application period begins on October 1st.

(Bonus points if you don’t start working on your application on the last day – you’ll have more time to ensure the details are correct!)

Formalities can be split into two categories:

  • Eligibility criteria, which answer the question, “Can I get funding here if I submit a strong application?” Check these first, as if you find out that you don’t fit the criteria, you can save yourself some precious time by not putting effort into an invalid application. Typical eligibility criteria include the types of organisations that can be funded (e.g. non-profits, companies or individuals), the minimum/maximum age of applicants, their place of residence and the type of project. If you don't meet these criteria, don't waste your time applying!
  • The second category covers all the other formalities, i.e. ensuring your application is correct. Check how, when and where to apply; what information is mandatory; what types of expenses can be funded (e.g. work hours, material costs and/or travel expenses); and what other rules apply to receiving funding. Many good ideas don’t get funded because of mistakes in these areas!

Prototype Fund specific mistakes we see too often – make sure you avoid them!

  • Answer all mandatory questions. If you answer “yes” to the question “Are you applying for Second Stage funding?”, make sure you also answer all the related questions.
  • Check that your place of residence matches Prototype Fund’s criteria. If you are applying alone, you must reside in Germany. If you are applying as a team, at least one person must reside in Germany; other team members can reside in Europe.
  • Prototype Fund only funds working hours, so don't include travel expenses or hardware.
  • Prototype Fund exclusively funds free and open-source software projects in the areas of data security, software infrastructure and alternatives to big tech. If your project does not fit these criteria, there is no need to apply! To prepare your application, read about our definitions of our funding focusses and tracks.
  • In the Innovation and Up and Coming funding tracks, we fund software development work, so most of the hours must be spent on that. If people are responsible for other aspects of the project, clearly state how many hours they will work on the project, and ensure this amount is appropriate.
  • Don't apply for less than 200 hours of work – the administration involved for everyone, including you, isn't worth the funding amount, and Prototype Fund's structure isn't set up for such small grants.

2. Be honest!

Funders read hundreds of proposals each year, and, believe it or not, we develop quite powerful instincts for spotting people who are trying too hard to sell us something that isn’t true. While it can be tempting to exaggerate your experience, the size of your project or the extent to which you meet the funding criteria, it generally doesn’t work.

This is not only because funders are usually quite good at detecting it, but also because, ideally, your proposal marks the beginning of your collaboration with the funder. If your proposal is selected and you have lied, your funder will probably find out at some point. If you don't meet the criteria, lying won't get you funding — your funder will find out when the administrative setup for your grant begins, if you are selected for funding.

If you meet the criteria for the fund but feel insecure about your expertise or some aspects of your project, be open about it! A candidate who acknowledges what they still need to learn, the open questions they need to address, and the areas where they’ll likely need assistance is often much more convincing than a candidate who pretends there’s no room for improvement and no unanswered questions. This demonstrates your ability to adapt to potential issues and your willingness to learn and improve your ideas during the funding phase.

Tricks that don’t work at Prototype Fund - don’t even try!

  • Adding the word 'infrastructure' to every other sentence to create the impression that your project aligns with the Prototype Fund's funding focus. If your project doesn’t fit our definition of infrastructure, this approach won't work!
  • Candidates very rarely submit ideas that don't have existing alternatives. When we ask about projects that already exist in your field, we want to know if you have done some research and how you have ensured that your project differs from existing technology. Pretending that there are no alternatives won't convince us that you have invented something totally new; it will make it look like you didn't do your homework before applying. Instead, use this field as an opportunity to explain why your project should exist alongside existing projects.
  • Don’t exaggerate your work experience. If you can't name any FOSS projects that you have actively worked on, don't list projects where we can't find any contributions by you. In this case, explain why you can't list experience: for example, are you very young and just starting out in the field, or have you worked on proprietary projects before?
  • We fund people, not institutions or companies. In every funding round, we review proposals and find many applications that are aimed at securing funding for companies, but try to hide this fact. We will notice, and if not, you’ll encounter issues when doing the paperwork further down the line. What is OK:
    • - You started a company/institution that is unrelated to your application.
    • - You started a company to enable you to do tech work (consulting, missions, etc.) in the area of your application, but your project is not a company project.
    • - You are a community contributor to a FOSS project that is also developed by a company/institution.

What is not OK:

  • You have founded or are a member of a company/institution that develops or maintains a project and benefits from it, and you apply to the Prototype Fund as a private person to work on that project.

3. Share!

Unless you are applying to a fund tailored to your very specific niche, chances are that the person who reads your application has general expertise in your field but does not know as much about it as you do. Don't assume that they know everything about the context in which you operate, the language you use, or your previous work!

As we've said many times: The best way to ensure that potential funders understand your proposal is to have someone who is not involved in your project proofread your draft and highlight anything that is unclear. Make sure you tell the jury something about the context of your project, such as the current status of the research, the background of the target audience and what has been accomplished in your ecosystem. Write out acronyms the first time you use them and briefly explain any very specific, niche vocabulary. Don't forget to share links to your previous work and tell the jury about your experience!

What helps us at Prototype Fund understand your proposal better:

  • Make sure that your proposal answers the following questions: 'What am I building, and how would I explain it to a non-expert?' and 'Who am I building it for?' before getting lost in technical details.
  • A way to learn more about you: GitHub or similar platforms are always helpful. If you have a personal website where you share content about your work or experience, that's great too! If you are applying as part of a team, please tell us what each team member will be responsible for, and how many hours they will be spending on the project (or what percentage of the total hours requested).
  • Also very helpful: Links to the free and open-source tools and technologies you mention, or a short description.
  • Tell us how you'll reach your users! Simply stating that you will set up a website or write documentation is not enough; everyone does that, and it doesn't work on its own. If you plan to attend events, publish on websites or form partnerships, provide one or two examples of where you plan to go, what websites you plan to publish on or who you plan to work with.

4. And also: a few Prototype Fund specific tips

  • Choose the right funding track! Prototype Fund is expanding, and for the first time this year, we will be offering three separate funding tracks. If you're looking for our good old classic Prototype Fund, apply for the Innovation track. I you're under 25 or a student, our Up and Coming track offers the same funding with more support and less competition. If you're building or strengthening alternatives to tech giants and want to (also) focus on reaching users, take a look at our Resilience track!
  • When you apply, you need to decide whether or not you want to apply for Second Stage funding: if you select "no", you won't be able to add it later. There's no pressure to apply for it — some projects are all about code, and that's OK — but think about it now. Note that the Second Stage application is mandatory for the Resilience track.